Debunking 5 Common Myths Surrounding Professional Indemnity Insurance

Have you ever wondered what would happen if a patient sued you for negligence? The thought alone can be daunting, underscoring the importance of safeguarding your practice and reputation. Professional indemnity insurance plays a crucial role in this protection, however, several misconceptions about this insurance persist, making it essential for every medical professional to understand and debunk these myths.

Myth #1: I've Never Made a Mistake, So I Don't Need Insurance

Medical practice is inherently complex, with unexpected complications, miscommunications, and accidental errors sometimes occurring entirely outside a doctor's control. Moreover, negligence lawsuits don't always hinge on a definitive mistake. Patient dissatisfaction, unrealistic expectations, administrative errors, or even a negative outcome despite following the highest standards of care can trigger litigation.

Myth #2: Professional Indemnity Insurance is Optional and Only for High-Risk Specialties

It’s easy to assume that professional indemnity insurance is optional since it isn’t a compliance need in India. But the reality is quite different. State regulations, institutional policies, and strong endorsements from medical bodies like the Indian Medical Association (IMA) highlight how crucial it is.

In India, the Consumer Protection Act (CPA) of 2019 has significantly impacted the legal landscape for medical practitioners. Under the CPA, the definition of what constitutes unfair trade practices has been broadened, encompassing a wider range of medical practices and interactions. The act has also made it easier for patients to file grievances in district consumer forums. This means that all doctors and healthcare providers are now more susceptible to legal actions, not just high-risk specialities. 

General physicians can be sued for medication errors, and psychiatrists for severe side effects of medications. In one recent case, a hospital and its doctors were ordered to pay ₹6 crore for negligence related to prescription and nutritional support. In fact, diagnostic errors and medication mistakes are among the leading causes of negligence claims. 

Myth #3: Professional Indemnity is Too Expensive

While the cost of professional indemnity insurance may seem like an additional burden, it's crucial to weigh it against the potentially devastating financial consequences of facing an uninsured negligence lawsuit. In India, settlements for medical negligence can range from ₹10 lakh to several crores, depending on the severity of the case.

The trade-off is clear. The cost of Doctor’s Professional Indemnity Insurance is relatively low compared to the high cost of litigation. For instance, a policy with ₹1 crore coverage can cost less than ₹5,000 per annum. Furthermore, you can tailor coverage to fit your needs and budget, ensuring comprehensive protection against specific risks like those associated with telemedicine or surgery. For instance, in telemedicine, there are risks such as misdiagnosis due to the absence of physical examinations or technical issues that may affect the quality of care. In surgical settings, risks include surgical errors, post-operative complications, and the complexities associated with high-stakes procedures. 

Therefore, by investing in Doctor’s Professional Indemnity Insurance, you can safeguard your finances, reputation, and peace of mind, allowing yourself to focus on providing the best care for your patients.

Myth #4: Professional Indemnity Insurance is Complex and Difficult to Obtain

A comprehensive professional indemnity policy typically covers legal and defence costs, unintentional breaches of confidentiality, defamation claims, and even fraudulent activities by staff involved in treatment. However, navigating through all these details can be challenging.

Choosing the right policy involves considering factors like the extent of coverage, retroactive date, handling of claims, and the cost of the policy. Additionally, it's important to compare different plans and providers to find the most cost-effective solution without compromising on coverage.

Platforms like Policybazaar for Business simplify this process significantly by offering user-friendly comparison tools and access to expert advisors who can clarify complex insurance terms and help tailor coverage to fit individual practice needs. This support makes obtaining PI coverage easy and ensures that you are adequately protected against potential legal and financial risks.

Myth #5: Standard Insurance Policies Provide Sufficient Coverage

Standard insurance policies often fall short when it comes to the specialised coverage required to address the unique risks faced by medical practitioners. Negligence lawsuits involve complex legal nuances and carry the potential for significant reputational damage. Additionally, risks such as loss of sensitive medical information can go beyond what standard insurance policies typically cover.

A thorough consultation with insurance experts is crucial to identify any gaps in your existing coverage. Tailoring your professional indemnity insurance ensures that you are fully protected against the specific risks of your practice. 


Don't let misconceptions about insurance leave you vulnerable to the potentially career-ending consequences of a negligence claim. Take charge of your future and proactively explore Doctor’s Professional Indemnity Insurance options with Policybazaar for Business. Their expert advisors will guide you towards a plan that safeguards your practice, allowing you to practice confidently with the knowledge that you are financially protected.

Ready to take the next step to safeguard your practice? Compare professional indemnity insurance plans today and save upto 88% :https://bit.ly/3yqY7X7


Medtalks is India's fastest growing Healthcare Learning and Patient Education Platform designed and developed to help doctors and other medical professionals to cater educational and training needs and to discover, discuss and learn the latest and best practices across 100+ medical specialties. Also find India Healthcare Latest Health News & Updates on the India Healthcare at Medtalks